BARE FEATS asks:
How much speed do I
gain in my Beige G3 if I replace the original 4 gig Fireball with a
$199 Maxtor 20 gig drive?
Tested 9/3/99.
© 1999 Rob Art Morgan, editor of BARE FEATS
rob-art@barefeats.com
Conclusion:
Adding this drive nearly doubled the write speed of the Beige G3.
It even outperformed a Yosemite G3/400 whose MacBench rating was
1090 (6 gig Fireball). It's a no brainer for any Mac user with the
need for a larger, faster IDE drive.
Test Configurations &
Procedures
- The test computer was a Beige G3 266
DT with a PowerLogix G3/466 ZIF upgrade and 128M of
RAM.
- The original drive was a Quantum
Fireball SE 4 gig. The replacement drive was a Maxtor Diamond Max
Plus 20.4 gig UltraDMA/66 EIDE. (The Maxtor drive was purchased
on special at CompUSA Honolulu for $199. There have been similar
specials at Onsale, Costco, and Staples. Check with
Deal-Mac.)
- I installed both drives as MASTER.
If you want to keep both drives connected, one must be set up as a
SLAVE. This only works if you have a REV 2 Beige G3. (See
Accelerate Your Mac's upgrade
instructions for IDE drives.)
- Before the tests were run, both
drives were freshly formatted with HD Setup version 1.7 and Mac OS
8.6 was installed. The Maxtor was divided into two partitions: 4
gig and 16 gig. The tests were run in the 4 gig partition
containing the System Folder.
- MacBench
5.0 attempts to simulate a
mix of real world disk operations. The disk cache was set to 512K
instead of the default setting to minimize effects of
caching.
- FWB's
Hard Disk Tookit has an
excellent Bench Test module that can give accurate information on
Sustained Read/Write, Random Read/Write, Transactions/Second, etc.
(There's a special price of $35.95 if you go to the
Special
Order page and inter "6sum99"
in the discount code field.)
A big THANK YOU to...
...David Tasaka of Lyte-On
for the use of his Beige G3 DT for testing
...PowerLogix
for the use of the G3/466 ZIF upgrade
Consult my Hot
Deals
page
for best prices on these and other products.
Or go see more Speed
Test Results
RETURN to
bare
feats main
index
© 1999 Rob Art Morgan, editor of
BARE FEATS
Gotta Question? Comment? Want to advertise?
Email rob-art@barefeats.com