Originally
posted 04/12/03 by rob-ART
morgan,
mad scientist I overheard a
converstion the other day in the local Apple store.
A young man was trying to decide between the
PowerBook G4/1000 and a Power Mac G4/1250. I butted
in to explain why his Digital Video projects would
render faster (both in foreground and background)
on dual cpu Power Mac. But the graphs below do a
better job of explaining. I decided to
compare various Macs running at 1000MHz (1GHz)
clock speed. It shows you the effect of dual
processors, as well as OS and subsystem
efficiencies. ANALYSIS If you are
considering using a single processor G4 (like the
17" PowerBook and single 1GHz Power Mac), take a
look at the Cinema 4D XL graph and the Photoshop
"MP" (Multi-processor) graph. What you see
happening there applies to many other MP aware apps
including iMovie, iTunes, Final Cut Pro, and iDVD.
Two CPU's are better than one. However, if you
ONLY use NOT-MP optimized apps like FileMaker Pro,
Bryce, MS Office and MS Explorer, then having a
second CPU will seem of no great advantage,
as illustrated in the Photoshop "SP" graph and the
Bryce 5 graph. However, if you run those
applications in parallel, Mac OS X smart
enough to use both CPU's, like in a previous
test session where I ran a Bryce render and
FileMaker script simultaneously (see graph
below). In other words,
it's never a liability to have two processors.
And if the rumors are true, the "Panther"
release of OS X will drive that point home even
harder. The only
advantage of single processor G4 Macs is LOWER
PRICE (as in the case of the iMac G4 and low end
Power Mac) and LOWER POWER CONSUMPTION (as in the
case of the PowerBook G4). Class
dismissed. (For details on
each real world test, read "HOW
I TEST.") Has Bare Feats helped
you? Say "thanks"... HOME
PAGE SPEED
TEST RESULTS
by Category HOT
DEALS
on speed upgrades (Bare Feats is hosted on a
G4 Power Mac server by MacDock.com)
SmallDog.com
has refurbished
towers, laptops, displays, etc., with 12 month
warranty.
with a donation.
"BARE facts on Macintosh speed FEATS"
Email webmaster at rob-art@barefeats.com