Has Bare Feats helped you? How about donating to Bare Feats?


BARE FEATS LAB - real world Mac speed tests

STORAGE SHOOTOUT:
'late 2012' iMac 27-inch HDD vs SSD
vs Fusion Drive

Originally posted Monday, December 24th, 2012, by rob-ART morgan, mad scientist

We have answers to the question, "What drive should I order for my 'late 2012' iMac 27-inch?" Since the 27-inch uses 3.5-inch HDDs, the drive choices and drive performance will be different from the 21.5-inch iMac which uses 2.5-inch HDDs. With the help of remote mad scientists, we were able to get test results on four of the five permutations available to 27-inch iMac buyers.

GRAPH LEGEND
SSD 768G = factory 768GB SSD SM768E (Samsung)
Fusion 1TB = factory 1TB Fusion Drive (128G SSD SM128E + 1TB Seagate ST1000DM003)
HDD 3TB = factory 3TB HDD (Seagate Barracuda 7200.14 ST3000DM001)
HDD 1TB = factory 1TB HDD (Seagate Barracuda 7200.14 ST1000DM003)

We used Intech Software's QuickBench 4 to measure the small random transfer speed of each drive. In the Standard test, it samples 4K, 8K, 16K, 32K, 64K, 128K, 256K, 512K, and 1024K random transfers. Then it computes an average from 5 cycles of each. (HIGHER number in Megabytes per Second is FASTER)

Next we used the Custom Sequential test in QuickBench to measure transfer speed of a 1GB test size. We use the average of 5 cycles. (HIGHER number in Megabytes per Second is FASTER)

INSIGHTS
The SSD is the fastest choice, obviously, if you are willing to cough up $1300. Also, it won't slow down in certain situations that affect the Fusion Drive's performance. (See "Fusion Reality Check" below.)

The $250 for the 1TB Fusion Drive is much easier to swallow. And for most users, it will provide plenty of speed -- especially in comparison to the HDD options.

In defense of the HDDs we tested, the Seagate Barracuda 7200.14 is the fastest 7200 rpm drive we have tested to date. The only HDD faster is the newest model of WDC Velociraptor 10,000 rpm 1TB drive -- which we happen to have running in our 6-core Mac Pro.

NOTICE ONE DRIVE IS MISSING?
Remember when we wrote, "four of the five"? The 5th drive CTO option for the 2012 iMac 27-inch:
the 3TB Fusion Drive (most likely a 128G SSD SM128E fused to a 3TB Seagate ST3000DM001). We simply did not have access to one or to any "remote mad scientist" that had one and was willing to test it. But you can infer the performance will be the same as the 1TB Fusion shown in the graphs -- as long as the SSD is in play. Once you overflow the SSD and are using the HDD, the performance will be the same as the 3TB factory HDD shown in the graphs.

CAUTION
Choose your drive carefully. You can't just pop in an upgrade if you are dissatisfied with your choice. Upgrading the drive requires disassembling the iMac. The first step is a bit icky and risky. You must use a heat gun to melt the adhesive holding the display assembly in place and use a guitar pick to pry the display away from the rear case containing all the components. Not for the faint of heart or someone with five thumbs on each hand. For more on this, see ifixit's disassembly instructions for the 21.5-inch 'late 2012' iMac. The initial part of the procedure is the same for the 27-inch 'late 2012' iMac.

CONSIDER EXTERNAL STORAGE OPTIONS
During our benchmarking of the 27-inch iMac, we used the newest LaCie Little Big Disk Thunderbolt (with dual 256G SSDs in RAID 0 set). At 700+MB/s READ and 500+MB/s WRITE it's faster than the internal Fusion Drive. In other words, you don't have to crack open your iMac to go faster -- unless you have your heart set on having an uncluttered desk. Otherwise, there are several excellent Thunderbolt enclosures you can buy which provide extra storage speed and space for your new iMac. Don't forget you have USB 3.0 ports now. We will be testing and reporting on two new, fast USB 3.0 enclosures.

A FUSION REALITY CHECK
Though the Fusion Drive is impressive, just be aware that it has its limits. In a test we conducted on various Fusion and cached storage products, we found that the speed dropped dramatically if the transfer size exceeded the unused space on the flash module "fused" to the hard disk drive. In the case of the 1TB Fusion Drive, the drop in speed was triggered when we attempted to transfer 88GB of HD video. That is an extreme test and hopefully won't affect the average user.

IN CASED YOU MISSED THEM,
we have several other test pages posted for the 'late 2012' iMac. See our index page for the full list of recent tests listed in reverse chronological order -- latest first.

Thoughts? Questions? Contact
Also, you can follow him on
Twitter @barefeats

WHERE TO BUY NEW APPLE PRODUCTS
Help us earn a commission by ordering your Apple products using this link:

For UK readers, visit Apple Store UK.

WHERE TO BUY THUNDERBOLT STORAGE DEVICES
Other World Computing has various Thunderbolt storage products from various manufacturers.

WHERE TO BUY USB 3.0 STORAGE DEVICES
Other World Computing has various USB 3.0 storage product from various manufacturers.
Amazon has
the Apricorn SATA-to-USB3 'bare' bus powered device for $23 (not counting HDD or SSD attached).

WHERE TO BUY MEMORY UPGRADES FOR the 'late 2012' IMAC
Other World Computing has an upgrade kit for the 21.5-inch iMac. It requires disassembly but they provide the tools and the installation video. They also offer memory upgrade kits for the 27-inch iMac.

Check with Trans International for memory kits for the iMac and other Mac models.

MaxUpgrades has memory kits for various models of iMac.

WHERE TO BUY PHOTOSHOP AND OTHER ADOBE PRODUCTS
See all the Special Offers for Photoshop and other products from Adobe USA.

Live OUTSIDE the USA? Go to THIS LINK and pick your Country. Then pick the type of Adobe online store (Home, Business, or Education).

Has Bare Feats helped you? How about helping Bare Feats?

copyright 2012 Rob Art Morgan
"BARE facts on Macintosh speed FEATS"
Email